Deleted
I have made 0 posts
Right now I'm Offline
I joined January 1970
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 29, 2015 22:04:33 GMT -6
So uhh... yeah, 90 pages in Twilight.
To be honest, I went in with no expectations. No, that's a lie. I went in expecting total mediocrity.
I'm sure there's a internet law out there which dictates that popularity can in some way, damage a piece of literature/fiction's reputation through various variables.
Like something that's popular and mediocre is seen as terrible where as something that's popular and good is seen as overrated.
Obviously I felt Twilight belonged to the former.
Which so far... it sort of does?
So here's the thing. Stephanie Meyre needs to read more. A lot more. She needs to read Shakespeare, classics, contemporaries, Harry Potter and Poor Things. Her prose is shameful, absolutely disgusting. How did this thing get published without some serious editing, (and if it did, then so god help me there's something seriously wrong in the publishing industry) I have no idea.
This stuff reads like bad fan fiction. Those awkward jumps between formal and informal language, that terrible habit of tell/don't show and that clunky dialogue wraps everything up into one big mess. But I can overlook this. I've read some good Light Novels that were, unfortunately, poorly translated. It's funny how an American novel sort of mimics that, but okay, cool, whatever.
So what's underneath that?
Now 90 pages is far too short time to be judging anything, but since everyone I trust knows this is a bad read, I'm already jumping to conclusions.
Cos you see, Steph has some pretty cool things being set up here. Any good writer worth his/her weight can make anything work. Gray can parody notions of Victorian Society and subvert Gothic Literature, Oda can repeat a formula for every arc and still create an original story, Martin married fantasy and history perfectly and Harry Potter is British Naruto.
So when you bring up something that could have been about... I don't know... adolescence, maturity, desire, forbidden love etc... you can batch up something that's AT LEAST a solid romance novel, nothing 'literary,' but good nonetheless which might have developed further.
And you have all the set pieces for it too!
Bella is immature, she complains over nothing, has a fear of blood (pretty symbolic if you ask me,) socially awkward because of her immaturity and to top it all of, she's legal! (Sex and sexual desire is a complex subject and brings forward many possible explorations of the human condition. So I'm only half joking here.)
So yeah, isn't this blank slate of a character almost perfect to toy around with?
Aaaaaand then you have Edward.
So fine, he's sort of like Peter Pan at the moment, but that's okay, this offers a chance to carry those same themes from the tale into this. And to be fair, there *is* a semblance of chemistry between them. Now I'm not saying this is Spice and Wolf/Geralt and Yeneffer chemistry. Not in the slightest, however I don't roll my eyes at their conversations. Progress!
Still... 90 pages in and I haven't gotten too much into their relationship yet, but I can tell why this is popular for young girls. Stephanie is playing on a ton of fantasies here, it's pretty evident with the way Edward just suddenly takes an interest in Bella with no prompting what's so ever. He's also the most gorgeous thing in the planet (Bella's gotta remind us of this y'know, just in case we forget,) smooth to a point of being cheesy and nobody seems to care when he's being an ass.
He's flawless!
Which is a bad thing.
But oh well.
Right now I'm giving it a 4/10.
5 being my 'average' score which should equate to uhh... Not sure really, not read many books that aren't awesome. Books are a big investment.
Ain't got time for shit.
|
|